Home improvement brands face a crucial question in the digital marketplace: How can a brand reach potential customers in an ever-developing online landscape? Thankfully, you’ve got two options: paid advertising and organic SEO. Which is better?

Think of it this way: Imagine building your dream home online. You can’t build with just one tool, like a hammer or a paintbrush; you need many different tools to do different jobs. Similarly, a successful home improvement brand needs paid advertising and organic SEO to build a long-lasting digital strategy. Let’s explore how each approach contributes to building a brand that attracts and converts customers.

Paid Ads: Targeting with Precision

Paid advertising offers immediate visibility, like Google Ads or social media campaigns. Bid on relevant keywords, and your brand appears front and center on search engine results in pages or user feeds. It’s akin to hiring a high-powered publicist who instantly gets your name in front of your target audience. 

“Paid ads are like your versatile toolbox – equipped for various tasks,” says Natalie Moffett, Digital Strategist at Porchlight. “Need to target a specific audience with laser precision? Use keyword targeting. Want to raise brand awareness quickly? Run social media campaigns. But remember: Just like maintaining your tools requires effort, paid ads need ongoing investment.”

Just like maintaining your tools requires effort, paid ads need ongoing investment.

Natalie Moffett, Digital Strategist, Porchlight


    • Fast Results: Need a burst of leads for a limited-time offer? Paid ads deliver. Attract a specific audience with laser-sharp targeting, ensuring your message reaches the right eyes.

    • Measurable Impact: Track every click, conversion and dollar spent. Paid ads offer unparalleled data on ROI, allowing you to fine-tune your campaigns for maximum impact.

    • Flexibility and Control: Adapt your messaging and targeting on the fly, responding to trends and competitor activity in real time. It’s marketing agility at its finest.


    • Ongoing Cost: Paid ads are like renting prime real estate – you continuously pay to stay visible. Stop the campaign, and your digital visibility fades quicker than a fresh coat of paint.

    • Short-Term Focus: Once the ad disappears, so does the traffic. Organic SEO builds sustained visibility, while paid ads offer temporary spikes.

    • Can Feel Impersonal: Generic banner ads lack the charm of engaging content. Organic SEO lets you build trust and genuine connections with your audience.

Organic SEO: Cultivating Growth

Organic SEO is the silent fighter, patiently optimizing your website to climb the search engine ladder. It involves keyword research, content creation and building backlinks, making your website so informative and relevant that search engines deem it worthy of top billing.

Natalie added, “Organic SEO is like laying the bricks of your online dream home. It’s a slow and steady process, but the result is a solid structure that attracts attention even without constant flashy decorations. By consistently creating high-quality content and optimizing your website, you’re building a reputation as a trusted expert in your industry, making you the go-to destination for potential customers.”

You’re building a reputation as a trusted expert in your industry, making you the go-to destination for potential customers.

Natalie Moffett, Digital Strategist, Porchlight


    • Long-Term Visibility: Once you gain momentum, organic SEO offers a lasting online presence. It’s like planting a sturdy oak tree that grows stronger with time.

    • Cost-Effective: While SEO requires initial investment and ongoing effort, it offers a more sustainable return on investment compared to the constant expense of paid ads.

    • Builds Trust and Authority: High-quality content establishes your brand as a reliable resource, making your audience perceive you as the neighborhood expert, not just a flashy flyer.


    • Slow and Steady: SEO gains traction gradually. Don’t expect overnight success – it’s a marathon, not a sprint. Be prepared for dedicated effort and consistent content creation.

    • Competitive Landscape: The online home improvement space is brimming with contenders. Standing out requires unique content, strategic optimization and adapting to algorithm changes.

    • Technical Knowledge Needed: SEO isn’t just about beautiful prose; understanding keywords, backlinks and website structure is essential for navigating the search engine labyrinth.

The good news is this isn’t a zero-sum game. The most effective strategy often blends both approaches. Paid ads can strategically boost targeted campaigns and promotions, while organic SEO builds a lasting foundation of website authority and visibility. Think of it like a well-designed home: Paid ads might be the eye-catching entryway, but organic SEO forms the solid framework and inviting interior. Combine the immediate impact of ads with the long-term value of SEO to create a winning online presence that attracts and converts potential customers.

Remember: Understanding your audience, resources and long-term goals is key. Choose the right tools, build consistently and adapt to the ever-changing digital landscape. Your online home improvement brand will stand strong, ready to welcome customers and thrive in the competitive online marketplace. So, grab your metaphorical hammer and paintbrush, and let’s build a brand that stands out in the digital neighborhood!

Like What You’re Seeing? Want More?